Updated October 2026
Ask who a broker acts for before you ask about anything else. You run a business, a job site or a farm, so your time is short and a wrong cover decision lands on you.
Proof matters more than promises. Pair these questions with our shorter checklist for Adelaide clients if you want a quick version. You succeed when you finish the call knowing who is accountable for your cover.
The questions to ask an insurance broker cover six areas: licence and qualifications, how they assess your risk, how they handle exclusions, what claims support they give, how they review your cover each year, and what information you should bring to the first conversation.
Key takeaways
- Get the claims process in writing: who lodges, who negotiates with the insurer, and who speaks for you in a dispute.
- Set an annual review and re-check cover whenever you add staff, vehicles, equipment or a new location.
- Gather your claims history, asset list and contracts before the first call so every disclosure answer is accurate.
1. What qualifications and licence authorisations does your brokerage hold?
This check shows who is legally responsible for the advice you receive. Do it before you share any detail about your business.
Think of it as asking a builder for a licence before the slab goes down. You would not skip that step on a job site, and your insurance deserves the same rigour. A licence is the minimum, though. Qualifications and memberships show how seriously a broker takes the work.
Ask about the people, not just the firm. Ask whether the firm is a member, and whether the person who will advise you holds Qualified Practising Insurance Broker (QPIB) status.
A plumber’s public liability needs differ from an accountant’s professional indemnity needs. We arrange public and products liability insurance and professional indemnity insurance, so we ask about your work before we talk about policies.
Once you know who you are dealing with, test how they think about your risk.
2. What process do you follow to assess specific business risk and coverage needs?
Every sound broker follows a risk assessment process that starts with your operations, not a product list. If a broker recommends cover straight away, the advice is a guess. Ask to hear the steps in order.
A good process has three parts: find the exposures, size them, then match them to cover. Finding exposures means asking what could go wrong on a normal day. A customer slips, a client relies on bad advice, a laptop is stolen, a supplier fails to deliver. Sizing them means asking how badly each event could hurt and how likely it is. Matching them to cover comes last, never first.
We work the same way. When we arrange landlord insurance, our process starts with a consult, where we learn about your property, risk profile, tenant arrangement and investment priorities. Only then do we compare policies.
Common gaps include an out-of-date sum insured, a business description that misses a side activity, and no cover for newer risks. If you store customer details or take payments online, ask about cyber insurance. If you are a director, ask about management liability insurance.
One call to a broker who compares insurers saves you hours of doing it yourself.
A comparison only helps if you can read what each policy leaves out, so the next question goes to the fine print.
3. How do you manage policy exclusions and coverage limitations across different insurers?
Your broker manages exclusions by reading each insurer’s wording against your actual work and listing every gap in writing. Exclusions are clauses that remove cover for certain events, activities or places. Good brokers answer with wording, not reassurance.
A policy is a promise, and the exclusions are the small print on that promise. Two policies with the same name can treat the same job very differently. One may exclude work at height, pollution or damage caused by advice you give, while another covers them with conditions. The name on the front page tells you little. The wording tells you everything.
Ask for a side-by-side comparison in writing. It should cover five items: key exclusions, sub-limits, conditions you must meet, the basis on which claims are accepted, and your duties after an incident. The claims basis matters most for professional indemnity. Many of these policies respond to claims made during the policy period, so a late notification can leave you exposed.
A broker with access to several insurers can often ask for changes or choose a stronger wording. A broker with only one insurer on its panel may not be able to.
For work vehicles, check how use for work, tools carried and named drivers change the policy.
Finally, set one test. If the answers make sense, you can make an informed decision. If they do not, you learned something important before you signed.
4. What claims support and dispute representation services do you provide?
A broker should lodge your claim, deal with the insurer and speak for you if the insurer disputes it. We support clients through the entire claims process, negotiating with insurers and third parties on their behalf. Ask any broker to describe each step in writing and to name the person who handles it.
Ask who answers the phone when a claim lands.
You might wonder if you could lodge a claim yourself. You can. The real question is who argues the wording while you are on the tools or serving customers. Insurers deal with claims every day, and you deal with yours once in a while. A broker closes that gap, because it reads the policy, gathers the evidence and negotiates for you.
Ask what happens when an insurer declines or reduces a claim. A strong broker explains the reason by pointing to the policy wording, challenges it where the wording allows, and tells you the next options.
Public liability claims show why this matters. This cover is designed to respond when a third party is injured, or their property is damaged, because of your business. Those claims often involve the other party’s lawyers as well as the insurer.
Your cover also has to stay current for the next claim, which brings us to reviews.
5. What ongoing review process keeps coverage aligned with changing operational requirements?
A broker should review your cover at least once a year and again whenever your business changes. Ask for the review dates, the questions asked at each review and who contacts whom. Without a set process, sums insured, asset lists and business descriptions drift away from reality. The gap then shows up at claim time.
Renewal is the obvious checkpoint, but it should not be the only one. Ask to see the comparison in writing before the renewal date, so you have time to decide without pressure. Treat the review as a conversation about your business, not a form to sign.
Changes between reviews matter just as much.
| When this changes | Ask your broker to re-check |
|---|---|
| You buy new equipment or a work vehicle | Property, motor and sums insured |
| You win a contract with an insurance clause | Public and products liability, professional indemnity |
| You start selling or taking payments online | Cyber cover |
| You open a second site or move premises | Property, liability and business description |
| You add or change directors | Management liability |
| You buy a rental property | Landlord cover |
That summary becomes your file. It protects you if a question about cover comes up later.
Where you are short of time, say so. A good broker adjusts the review to suit you, with a phone call, a visit to your workplace, or a short written update. We meet clients in our Adelaide CBD office or anywhere convenient for them.
A review is only as good as the information you bring to it, so the last question turns to your side of the table.
6. What information should you prepare before speaking with a general insurance broker?
Before you call a general insurance broker, gather your claims history, asset list, contracts, business description and current policy documents. This preparation also protects you, because insurers rely on what you disclose when they accept your risk. Work through this list in order:
- Write a plain description of every activity your business does, including side jobs and work for related companies.
- List your claims and incidents, with dates, outcomes and the insurer’s reasons.
- Collect your current policy schedules and wordings, including cover limits, sums insured and renewal dates.
- List your assets, vehicles, equipment, premises and locations, and who owns each.
- Gather contracts and leases that set insurance requirements.
Most of this sits in your email and your filing cabinet already. Gathering it takes less time than explaining it twice.
What not to tell your insurance company?
Hide nothing that is relevant to the risk. Do not play down past claims, leave out side work or guess a figure you have not checked.
The duty differs by policy type. For business insurance, the duty of disclosure generally asks you to tell the insurer what you know, or what a reasonable person would know, is relevant. This is general information, not advice, so ask your broker how it applies to you.
What should you keep out? Keep out guesses and opinions. State facts you can back with a document.
Finally, ask what happens after the first call. A broker who answers clearly has a process, and a process is what you are paying attention to.
How do good answers differ from weak ones?
Strong answers give you evidence you can check, while weak answers give you comfort you cannot. A strong answer names a number, a document or a person. A weak answer repeats a slogan. Use this table on any call, with any broker, in any state.
| Question | A strong answer | A weak answer |
|---|---|---|
| Licence | Gives a licence or authorised representative number you can check | Says “we are fully licensed” and moves on |
| Risk process | Describes steps and asks about your work first | Names a product in the first minute |
| Insurers | Says how many insurers it compared and why | Offers a single option |
| Exclusions | Shows wording and lists gaps in writing | Says “you are covered for everything” |
| Claims | Names who lodges, negotiates and speaks for you | Says “just call the insurer” |
| Reviews | Sets review dates and change triggers | Contacts you only at renewal |
| Information | Lists what to bring and explains disclosure | Tells you to skip detail to save time |
These questions ask a broker to show its work. A broker who welcomes them is telling you something good. A broker who dodges them is telling you something too.
The first three questions in this guide also work when you speak with a health or life insurance agent. For product-specific questions in those fields, ask the agent to explain their authority to advise on that product.
Which extra questions apply to your type of cover?
Each type of cover has one extra question that reveals more than any general one. Ask it after the six above. The right question depends on whether you run a trade, a practice, a farm, a rental property or a home.
| Cover | The extra question to ask |
|---|---|
| Public and products liability | Does it respond to injury or damage caused by my work or product, and does it meet my contract requirements? |
| Professional indemnity | Is the policy claims-made, and what happens to my past work if I change insurers? |
| Cyber | Which events trigger cover, and what response support sits inside the policy? |
| Management liability | Which people are covered, and which allegations are excluded? |
| Farm | Do machinery, livestock, crops and sheds sit under one policy, and how are sums insured set? |
| Landlord | How does the policy treat tenant-caused damage and rental loss? |
| House and contents | How is the building sum insured set, and who checks it? |
| Motor and work vehicles | How does use for work, tools carried and named drivers change the policy? |
That is where a broker who compares insurers with one call earns its place, because it keeps your policies lined up rather than scattered.
Conclusion: take these questions into one call
A broker who answers them plainly has earned a closer look. Everything else follows from that.
When you are ready, talk to Westphalian Insurance Brokers. Request a quote or get in touch, and bring your current policy. We meet clients at our Adelaide CBD office or anywhere convenient for you. This article is general information, as at 2026, not personal advice. Call us on (08) 8232 3118 to book a time.
Important information
This article is general information only and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it is appropriate for you, and read the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before deciding on any insurance product. Speak with us for advice on your own circumstances.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are some good questions to ask my insurance agent?
Good questions to ask your insurance agent start with who they act for, which licence and qualifications they hold in Australia, and how they assess your risk. Ask them to explain each step in order, then ask who will lodge and negotiate your claim with the insurer. Request the exclusions in writing so you can compare them with your actual work.
What are the 5 C’s of insurance?
The 5 C’s of insurance are a general industry shorthand, so ask your broker at Westphalian Insurance Brokers to explain them in plain terms. Then ask how each one applies to your policy. Test the answer against the exclusions, sums insured and disclosure duties that shape what your cover actually pays.
What are the qualities of a good insurance agent?
Qualities of a good insurance agent include clear licensing, a documented risk assessment process and written answers rather than reassurance. Look for Qualified Practising Insurance Broker (QPIB) status where it applies, and a willingness to compare insurers. A strong agent also reviews your cover each year and whenever your business changes.
What not to tell your insurance company?
What not to tell your insurance company? Hide nothing relevant to the risk. Do not play down past claims, leave out side work or guess a figure you have not checked. Under the duty of disclosure for business insurance in Australia, tell the insurer what you know, or what a reasonable person would know, is relevant, and state facts you can back with a document.
Who does an insurance broker act for, and why should you ask this before anything else?
An insurance broker may act for you, the insurer, or both, so ask who they act for before anything else. Their loyalty determines whose interests the advice serves in Australia. Ask this first, because every later answer about cover, claims and reviews depends on it.
What qualifications, licence authorisations and memberships should a brokerage hold, and how can you check them?
A brokerage should hold a licence or authorised representative number you can check, along with any memberships and staff qualifications. Ask for the number in writing, ask whether the firm is a member, and ask whether the adviser holds QPIB status. Confirm the details before you share any information about your business.

